How to Compare Roofing Quotes in Texarkana & Surrounding Areas

So, you followed your insurance company’s advice and got three roofing quotes. Now you’re staring at three very different numbers:

• One low (almost too good to be true)

• One high (way above the rest)

• One in the middle

Which one should you trust?

As a homeowner in Texarkana, Idabel, Broken Bow, or Nashville, Arkansas, this decision matters. Most people don’t know how to read a roofing estimate — and some roofing companies like it that way. Choosing the wrong one could leave you with leaks, hidden costs, or a roof that won’t last.

Here’s how to break down roofing quotes the right way.

1. Roofing Materials: Don’t Let Contractors Cut Corners

The first red flag in a roof estimate is the materials line. Ask questions like:

• Shingles: Are they quoting basic 3-tab shingles, or premium Class 3 or Class 4 impact-resistant shingles designed to last in Arkansas and Texas storms?

• Underlayment: Is it cheap felt paper or a quality synthetic underlayment?

• Ice & Water Shield: Is it included in valleys and around roof penetrations?

• Ventilation: Are they upgrading your ridge vent or just leaving old box vents?

Some Texarkana roofers pad their numbers by charging for premium shingles but installing cheaper ones. Always demand a detailed line-item list of materials.

2. Labor & Details: The Difference Between a Roof That Lasts and One That Fails

If your roofing quote just says “Roof replacement: $10,000” — that’s a problem. You need to see the details:

• How many crew members will be on the job?

• How long will it take?

• Is cleanup included (every nail, every shingle)?

• Are they replacing flashing or reusing old, rusted pieces?

The cheapest roofing estimates usually skip these details, leading to shortcuts and problems. The higher roofing quotes often cover everything: full crew, proper tear-off, new flashing, correct ventilation, and a thorough cleanup.

Remember — in roofing, the lowest bid often costs you more in the long run.

3. Roofing Warranties: Protect Your Home Investment

A quality roofing company doesn’t just install shingles; they stand behind their work. Look for:

• Manufacturer’s warranty (covers shingles)

• Workmanship warranty (covers installation)

• Contractor responsibility for registering the warranty

If your roofer offers no workmanship warranty, that’s a deal breaker.

4. Transparency: The “Trust but Verify” Test

This is how you spot the roofing companies you can trust in Texarkana and surrounding areas:

Ask them to break down the quote by the square and compare it to the local average roofing price per square.

If they dodge or refuse, that’s a red flag. A reliable roofer will gladly explain their pricing and show you local averages.

5. Hidden Costs: Watch Out for Change Orders

Some roofers in Arkansas and Texas will give you a cheap satellite-based quote without climbing on your roof. Once the job starts, they “find” rotten decking or surprises, and hit you with expensive change orders.

That $7,200 roof quickly becomes $12,000 — and now you’re paying more than the middle bid for lower-quality work.

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Best Roofing Contractor in Texarkana, AR

When you line up three roofing quotes, don’t just look at the final number. Compare materials, labor, details, and warranties. And always apply the trust but verify test.

At Chella Roofing, we do things differently. We’ll:

Break down your quote by the square

Show you how our pricing compares to local averages

Provide a detailed line-item estimate

Stand behind our work with a solid workmanship warranty

We’re large enough to serve, but small enough to care — and we take pride in being one of the most trusted roofing companies in Texarkana, Idabel, Broken Bow, and Nashville, AR.

Serving Arkansas, Texas, Oklahoma, and Louisiana

Watch the full video here: https://youtu.be/7dQqqV7d290?si=wDnzHJd_KwxOdh5g